Town council defeats legal challenge over discounted pitches for long-term traders

Leighton Linslade Town Council, in Central Bedfordshire, decided to give discounts to traders who had occupied pitches in Leighton Buzzard’s market for at least five years to encourage them to stay in business and support the market.

It was challenged by trader Victoria Harvey, who argued that the council failed to consult on the matter.

The council said Judge Marc Dight confirmed that while it did not have a duty to consult, the consultation process undertaken with traders on pitch fees, “was thorough, measured and appropriate”.

A council statement said: “At a time when traditional markets are facing stiff competition from on-line retailers and discount stores, the decision to continue to recognise and celebrate loyalty by way of reduced rents will undoubtedly be welcome news to our market traders.

“For those who have yet to receive long service discount, the rents offered by the town council remain highly competitive when compared to other markets of a similar size, character and stature.”

The council said a cost capping order previously set by the High Court at £4,000 was varied by Judge Dight so Ms Harvey will be required to pay £20,000, which “will be used to offset the town council’s costs in having to defend the challenge brought about by Miss Harvey”.

Leighton Buzzard has a twice weekly charter market, complemented by a crafts market and a farmers’ market.

Mark Smulian